The suitcase murder mystery: What happened to Bill McGuire? | Nightline

1. She smeared menstrual blood all over the toilet when I asked her not use my tampons. She’s insane. Frightening. Dead behind the eyes. I lived out at 3am unannounced. That she killed Bill and cut him up is beyond believable.

2. Murdering cow

3. Dud she smirked when she said that. Microfacial expressions reveal so much about someone's deceitful ways. She did it and was proud

4. I don't believe one single thing coming out of her mouth. She's a liar!!

5. You can't talk this one pretty…it's frightening how self righteous she is

6. OMG OMG absolutamente unbelievable how she did that to herself she is so so petite and isn't not fisicly evidence at all I was in the county jail when she was there she's small as hell I really really don't think she did it by herself if she did it

7. Has anyone heard of a theory of how she supposedly did it?

8. Saying a white man can be calculating is like saying a black man might listen to hip hop.

9. Where's the rest of this story? I can't find the second half of your Nightline story. Do you have a link to it that you can post here? Thanks

10. If she didn’t do it why is she just telling us her motive? This is just bashing him. She did it as plain as the smile on her face.

11. She has an answer for everything. She is a bad liar. Rags Bill every chance she can. Very sad

12. She killed him in Atlantic city either in a motel or on the beach. She went there twice while he was missing.

13. Am I the only one disturbed by the term “fresh 🦵🏻 🦵🏻 “ used?

14. I've never thought she did it. IF she did she would have to have had help. He was cut up for Heaven's sake, I don't think she had that in her. What better way to frame her than to use her suitcases!!!

15. Fact

16. legs are look fresh like frozen meat .

17. I real believe that she did it , all that evedence presented by detectives it could not be someone else! Come on she brought two guns. And she was a controlling freak kind of personality, entiltled. If She could not have him not anyone else could. Moreover she manipulated him to buy a house while she knew very well the marriage was on rocks. And she told her lover ”the so called Dr.” When he asked quote ”why are you buying the house while you are thinking about divorce ? Melanie said ” quote ” I shall take care of it ” Mh 🤔ooops meaning 🥱! Ooh the evidence goes on and on. She belongs where she is . RIP Bill.

18. If they ever do a movie about this disgusting murder, I think Mary Manstrantonio should play her.

19. The garbage bags got her

20. Tony's sister in scarface

21. Maybe her lover the doctor did it

22. I just listen to the podcast "Direct Appeal Melanie McGuire" and she is totally GUILTY".. everything fits.. no doubt about it.. she bought the gun two days before the murder, she moved the car, like Carol Sigg said below… She’s a calculated killer and a liar

23. Melinda is a liar, you can see she is lying to the reporter she can't even look the reporter in the eyes

24. LETS BE CLEAR. She didn't call him because she knew he wouldn't answer!

25. The fact that she never tried to find her husbands killers is a red flag

Comments are closed.